There’s a new chapter unfolding on the Montauk waterfront, and Sasha Benz is helping write it. The longtime Montauk resident, entrepreneur, and creative visionary has joined the team at Gosman’s Dock, bringing her distinctive perspective to one of the East End’s most recognizable destinations.
For more than eight decades, Gosman’s Dock has been synonymous with Montauk summers, from fresh seafood and fishing boats to waterfront dining and sunset views. Now, under new ownership and with Benz lending her creative expertise, the historic property is looking toward the future while remaining rooted in the traditions that made it a local institution.
“The idea is a village, not a venue. Coffee on the dock in the morning, shopping in the afternoon, somewhere for the kids to play, sunset drinks, dinner that keeps you there,” says Benz. “Everything working together, a central place we can be proud of in our town.”
Originally from Australia, Benz moved to New York City at 24 before heading east in 2014 to become Creative Director of The Surf Lodge. In 2018, she founded Wyld Blue, her curated retail concept with locations in Montauk and Aspen. Today, she calls Montauk home, raising her three young children in the community and bringing a personal understanding of what makes the town special to her latest endeavor.
“Morning at Gosman’s belongs to the fishermen. That doesn’t change,” she explains. “The fleet and the market are the real thing, and anything we add must earn its place next to them. Authenticity over luxury — that’s the first rule I wrote down and it’s the one I’ll defend the hardest.”
A New Chapter for a Montauk Institution
Founded in 1943 by Robert and Mary Gosman, the waterfront business began as a modest dock serving local fishermen before evolving into a destination encompassing restaurants, retail shops, a seafood market, and marina operations. In 2024, after more than 80 years under the Gosman family, the property was acquired by Stephen Deckoff, founder of Black Diamond Capital Management, and his son, Stephen E. Deckoff. Deckoff’s daughter, Laura, has since relocated to Amagansett full-time to oversee the property’s revitalization and management.
Together with Benz, the team envisions a more cohesive waterfront experience, where dining, shopping, family activities, and community programming come together while preserving the working harbor’s character. “Everyone in Montauk has a Gosman’s memory. Mine start in 2010. Watching the boats come in, sunsets on the water, summers with my kids,” says Benz. “It doesn’t need to be reinvented. It just needs room for new memories alongside the ones people already have. That’s why I said yes.”
For the Deckoff family, the investment represents a long-term commitment to the property and its place within the community. “We are thrilled to welcome Sasha to the team,” says Steve Deckoff. “Her deep connection to Montauk, understanding of the community and vision for the future align perfectly with our long-term goals for the property.”
As plans take shape, Benz is inviting local businesses, artists, and entrepreneurs to contribute ideas for events, retail concepts, and collaborations. Additional details surrounding new dining, shopping, family experiences, and programming are expected in the coming months.
For Benz, the goal is simple: create a place that future generations will continue to call their own. “Every generation should leave it stronger than they found it,” she says. “If my kids can bring their own kids down to this dock one day and it’s still the heart of Montauk, then I’ve done my job.”
